Guide, 10 Nov 2026, read 10 Nov 2026
A policy exception needs a reason, an approver, an end date and a record
Say what an exception is
An exception is an approved departure from a written policy for a specific person or case. It is not a new rule, and it is not a manager's private arrangement. If the same exception is requested three times, the policy is wrong or unclear, and it should be changed.
State in the policy itself that exceptions can be made, who can approve them and where they are recorded. A policy that says nothing about exceptions invites informal ones.
Separate exceptions from legal duties
Some departures are not discretionary. In the US, a reasonable accommodation for a qualified person with a disability is a legal duty unless it causes undue hardship, and the EEOC guidance describes an interactive process. In the UK, employers must consider reasonable adjustments for disabled workers. A request for a change to a policy for one of these reasons should go through the accommodation or adjustment route, not the exception form.
Flexible working requests in the UK also follow their own process, with a decision required. Make it clear in the policy which route applies, so a person is not told no under the wrong one.
Write down five things
Keep medical information separate from the main log and limit access to those who need it.
- Who asked, and for which policy and version.
- The reason, in a sentence, without medical or private detail beyond what is needed.
- The decision, who made it and the date.
- The conditions and the end date, or a review date.
- Whether the exception sets a precedent, and if so what the criteria are.
Decide who approves what
Match the approver to the risk. A manager can approve a one-off change to a working hour. A department head approves an exception that costs money or changes a pay term. The People lead approves anything touching a legal duty, and counsel is asked when the answer is unclear. Put the thresholds in a table in the policy, so a manager knows where a request goes.
Avoid giving the same person the power to request and approve. It is a control that matters more as the company grows.
Review the log every quarter
Read the log as a set. Look for repeats, for patterns by team, manager, gender or other protected characteristic, and for exceptions that never ended. Where the same exception keeps appearing, change the policy. Where one team gets more exceptions than another, ask why.
Close each exception on its end date by confirming that it ended or renewing it with a new decision. Keep the log for as long as the employee's record is kept; US federal regulations require personnel records to be kept for one year, and a longer period is common.
A short form that works
A one-page form is enough: the requester, the policy and version, what is asked, why, the proposed end date, the approver, the decision and the date. Add a field for whether the person involved has asked for an accommodation or adjustment, so the request is routed to the correct process. Keep the form in a system with an audit trail, so changes to the decision are recorded.
Test the form on three recent cases before you publish it. If a case does not fit, a field is missing, and it is easier to add the field now than to explain a gap in the record later.
Sources
- Reasonable accommodation and undue hardship, EEOC, read 10 Nov 2026
- Reasonable adjustments, GOV.UK, read 10 Nov 2026
- Flexible working, GOV.UK, read 10 Nov 2026
- Recordkeeping requirements, EEOC, read 10 Nov 2026
Last reviewed 10 Nov 2026.