FAQ, read 10 Nov 2026
30 questions, answered from the data
See the rankingRead the method
- How many policies does a company of 50 people actually need?
- Most companies of that size need a short core set: equal opportunity and anti-harassment, time off and sick leave, code of conduct, acceptable use of systems, data privacy, expenses and a complaints route. Add location-specific pages for each state or country where staff work. Add more only when a real incident or a law requires one.
- Should we have a handbook or a set of separate policies?
- Many People teams of one to five keep a short handbook that links to individual policies. Each policy then has its own owner, version and review date, so a change does not mean reissuing a 60-page document. The handbook stays the front door and the acknowledgement point.
- Do employees have to sign the handbook?
- There is generally no law that requires a signature on a handbook, but a record that each person received and read the current version is useful evidence in a dispute. Many employers collect an acknowledgement at hire and again when a material change is made. Keep the record with the version number and date.
- What is the difference between a policy, a procedure and a guideline?
- A policy states the rule and why it exists. A procedure lists the steps to follow, such as how to submit a request or who approves it. A guideline gives advice that people may adapt. Keeping them apart makes the policy short and lets the procedure change without a new sign-off.
- How often should policies be reviewed?
- Review each policy at least once a year and again whenever the law, the structure of the company or a process changes. Assign a review date and an owner on every page. A calendar that lists policies by month spreads the work across the year.
- Can one handbook cover both US and UK employees?
- One handbook can carry shared values and a code of conduct, but entitlements, notice, sick pay, discipline and termination differ by country. The usual approach is a common core plus a country supplement for each legal entity. Employees should only see the version that applies to them.
- Do we need a separate policy for each US state?
- Not always a separate policy, but state law changes the content of leave, pay, meal break, final pay and posting rules. Many employers keep a state addendum for each state with staff and a rule for adding a new one when the first employee is hired there. Check requirements before the start date.
- What should a time off policy say about carryover?
- It should state the cap, the date by which carried-over time must be used and what happens to anything above the cap. It should also say how time is treated if the employee could not take it because of leave or illness. In the UK, rules on statutory holiday carryover apply in some situations.
- Is unlimited paid time off a good idea?
- It can work for some teams, but employees often take less time than under a fixed allowance unless managers set a minimum and model it. Some US states treat accrued vacation as wages payable at exit, which unlimited policies avoid, and in the UK statutory holiday rights still apply. Decide the minimum, the approval route and how bank holidays and sickness are handled.
- What is a policy exception and who should approve it?
- An exception is an approved departure from the written policy for a particular person or case. A named role, usually the policy owner or a People lead, should approve it in writing, with an end date and a reason. Keeping a log allows the company to show consistent decisions.
- How do we handle a manager who ignores a policy?
- Start with the policy owner and the manager's own manager, and restate the rule in writing. If the behavior continues, the company's disciplinary procedure applies to managers as it does to anyone. Check whether the policy is clear or whether the manager was never told.
- How do we get people to read policy updates?
- Send a short summary of what changed and why it matters, link to the full text and set a date to acknowledge. Keep the update to one subject at a time. Send a reminder to those who have not responded and give managers a list.
- What should we record when an employee acknowledges a policy?
- Record who acknowledged, which policy and version, the date and time, and how the acknowledgement was captured. Keep the signed or clicked record for as long as the employee's file is kept. A version history lets you show which text applied on any date.
- Can employees opt out of an AI tool in HR processes?
- It depends on the place and the tool. Some laws, such as New York City Local Law 144, require notice and a bias audit for automated employment decision tools, and data protection law gives people rights over solely automated decisions. A policy should list each tool and the way a person can ask for human review.
- What belongs in an AI use policy for an HR team?
- List approved tools and purposes, what data may and may not be entered, who reviews outputs, how decisions are explained to candidates and staff, and how the tools are tested for bias. Name an owner and a review cycle. Under the EU AI Act, tools used in recruitment and worker management are classed as high-risk.
- When does the EU AI Act apply to employment tools?
- The European Commission's AI Act page gives 2 December 2027 as the date the high-risk rules for systems used in employment apply. The ban on prohibited practices and the AI literacy duty have applied since 2 February 2025. Employers with EU staff should keep an inventory of tools now.
- What is the difference between a grievance and a disciplinary procedure?
- A grievance is a concern raised by an employee; a disciplinary procedure is how an employer deals with conduct or performance issues. In the UK both follow the Acas Code of Practice: tell the person, hold a meeting, decide and offer an appeal. The handbook should have a separate page for each.
- What does a UK employer have to put in writing?
- UK employers must give new employees a written statement of employment particulars, covering items such as pay, hours, holiday and notice, and this has to be provided from day one. The handbook can hold some of the detail by reference. Keep the statement and the handbook consistent.
- What must an employer keep on file for a new US hire?
- Every US employer must complete Form I-9 for each new hire and keep it, and follow federal and state record-keeping rules for payroll and personnel records. EEOC regulations require personnel records to be kept for one year. Keep I-9s separate from the main personnel file where practical.
- How long should we keep old versions of policies?
- Keep every earlier version for at least as long as the longest period in which a claim about it could arise, and check the rules of each country you operate in. Many employers keep them for the life of the company. Archive rather than delete.
- Who should own each policy?
- The person closest to the subject: finance owns expenses, IT owns acceptable use, People owns leave and conduct. The owner is accountable for accuracy, review and answering questions. List the owner on the policy page.
- How do we stop the People team being the help desk for policy questions?
- Make each policy easy to find and search, put the answer to common questions at the top of the page, and give managers a short guide to the ten questions they are asked most. Track repeated questions and fix the page that caused them. Keep a simple route for cases that need judgment.
- What should a lawyer review in the handbook?
- Have a lawyer check the at-will and employment status language, leave and pay rules for each state or country, anti-discrimination and harassment provisions, monitoring and data protection wording, and anything on restrictive covenants. They should also review the process for changes. A review every year or after a major law change is common.
- Do we need a whistleblowing policy?
- In the UK, workers are protected when they make a protected disclosure, and most employers have a policy that names who receives reports and promises protection from retaliation. In the US, various federal and state laws protect reporting, and certain employers need a hotline. Even where not required, it is a good page to have.
- How should we handle a flexible working request?
- In the UK, an employee can make a request from the first day, and the employer must handle it in a reasonable manner and give a decision. A policy sets out how to apply, who decides, the timeline and the appeal. Record the outcome and the reasons for it.
- What should a probation policy say?
- State the length, the review points, what support is given and who decides at the end. Say what notice applies during and after probation. In the UK, Acas notes unfair dismissal protection will apply after six months from 1 January 2027, so check any probation period beyond that.
- Should we do background checks on all hires?
- Only if the role warrants it and the law allows it. EEOC guidance says policies that exclude people with certain records can have a disparate impact unless job related and consistent with business necessity. Many employers check after a conditional offer and review each result against the duties of the role.
- Can we require a drug test?
- Rules vary by state and country. Under the Americans with Disabilities Act, tests for current illegal use of drugs are not medical examinations, but asking about prescription medicines is restricted. Some states limit testing or protect lawful off-duty use, so write the policy by location and role.
- What happens to the policies when we acquire a company or add an entity?
- Treat the new entity as a separate legal employer until employment terms are formally harmonized. Keep its handbook in place, map it against yours, and plan a single consolidation date. Tell employees what will change and when.
- What is the cheapest way to start a policy audit?
- List every policy with owner, version, last review date and who acknowledged. Mark the ones that are over a year old, have no owner or conflict with each other. Fix the missing owners first, then the oldest pages.
Last reviewed 10 Nov 2026.