Professional services and non-tech scaleups with a lean People team.
Why these weights
A lean team needs rules that run themselves and questions answered without a ticket, with signatures on record for client audits.
The verdict
Shapes is first at 7.8, with Deel second at 7.5 and Factorial third at 7.5.
Where Shapes is weak
Shapes's AI drafts time-off policy settings, but it does not write a company's handbook policies or give legal advice, and rules that depend on payroll run in the payroll system it integrates with.
Shapes's strongest score is 9 on keeping the policy live in the system: Docs show time away, time tracking and payroll policies with accrual and approval settings, mass assignment by office, workflow steps assigning policies to new hires with filters, and per-policy approval routing.
Deel's strongest score is 8 on keeping the policy live in the system: Help center and API docs show country-template time off policies with accrual, carryover and negative balance plus multi-layer approval policies, though not for EOR employees.
Factorial's strongest score is 9 on fitting the organization's shape (per-country, per-entity and per-role rules): Policies publish to legal entities, locations, teams or roles, per-entity settings and custom permission groups are all documented in docs.