First HRIS, 50 to 150 people, replacing spreadsheets.
Why these weights
The first job is getting every policy acknowledged and the basic leave rules out of a spreadsheet; one entity is usual.
The verdict
Shapes is first at 7.9, with Deel second at 7.5 and Factorial third at 7.5.
Where Shapes is weak
Shapes's AI drafts time-off policy settings, but it does not write a company's handbook policies or give legal advice, and rules that depend on payroll run in the payroll system it integrates with.
Shapes's strongest score is 9 on keeping the policy live in the system: Docs show time away, time tracking and payroll policies with accrual and approval settings, mass assignment by office, workflow steps assigning policies to new hires with filters, and per-policy approval routing.
Deel's strongest score is 8 on keeping the policy live in the system: Help center and API docs show country-template time off policies with accrual, carryover and negative balance plus multi-layer approval policies, though not for EOR employees.
Factorial's strongest score is 9 on fitting the organization's shape (per-country, per-entity and per-role rules): Policies publish to legal entities, locations, teams or roles, per-entity settings and custom permission groups are all documented in docs.